Catalogue | Volume 23, Shanghai Legal Research, 2021
In order to further promote the dissemination and application of academic research results of law, from 2019, the Shanghai Law Society and China HowNet strategically cooperated to publish the Shanghai Law Research online, and published 24 volumes of large-scale original academic library of law with a scale of 10 million words every year, which was included in the full text of China HowNet, and the electronic version could be queried and downloaded online. The collection of Shanghai Legal Studies focuses on the annual production of quality and distinctive contents in the legal field. Up to now, more than 2,700 articles in all 72 volumes in 2019, 2020 and 2021 and 1-8 volumes in 2022 have been fully edited, and 2,370 articles have been launched on China HowNet, with a single download volume of 3,000 times and a total download volume of nearly 500,000 times.
Contents of Volume 23 of Shanghai Legal Studies in 2021
-southeast university anthology
Subject: crime and supervision of the rule of law
Frontier problem
On the Predicament and Outlet of Minors’ Right to Fair and High Quality Education
Zhou tong
On the Judicial Review of the Invalidation of Administrative Agreement
Wang zhengchao
On the Expansion of the Scope of Compensation for Spiritual Damage of Administrative Tort —— Based on the Interpretation of National Compensation for Spiritual Damage
Chen wulve
Predicament and outlet of full-time fact trial of people’s jurors
Chen Qian
Study on the Setting System of Temporary Administrative Measures for Major International Activities
Yang jiahao
On the "Poverty Alleviation" Precise Governance of National Folk Literature and Art from the Perspective of Utilitarianism
Li Yuanhua
On the legal responsibility for the loss caused by travel restriction in public health emergencies
Yu jiacheng
Supervise the rule of law
Optimization of the Connection Path of the Concept of "Fa Fa"
Liu Hao
Visualization Analysis of Research Hotspots and Frontiers of Supervision Law in China —— Bibliometric Research Based on cnki Database
Cui xuemeng
Feasibility analysis of setting prescription system in supervision law
Lu mengjiao
A probe into the principle of the right relief of the investigated person in the supervision procedure
Niu Mengqian
Research on National Supervision Compensation System from the Perspective of Legislation
Chen Shengnan
Criminal rule of law
The expansion of subjectivism in criminal law legislation and its countermeasures
Xu Jing
A study on the phenomenon that the sentencing suggestion of pleading guilty and admitting punishment is not adopted
Dai Minmin
On the implementation of "the same case and the same sentence" in criminal cases
Liu Meng
Reconstruction of prosecution system for dealing with crimes only after telling them.
Xu yunjie
Judicial Identification and Reflection on the Crime of Obstructing the Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases in the Form of Dual Crimes —— Taking 64 Judgment Documents as the Starting Point
Liu xiaoning
An Analysis of Criminal Law Doctrines of "Rape and Trafficking of Women"
Xuesong Wang
Analysis on Criminal Responsibility of Stealing and Digging Black Soil
Wang Xiaoli
The applicable limit of the crime of infringing on the reputation and honor of heroic martyrs
Biezhi
Advocating the Diversification of Criminalization of Internet Fraud
Gong wenbo
The legal interest structure and development of the crime of illegal business operation
Zong shaohao
Judicial determination of the crime of infringing citizens’ personal information in the era of civil code
Wang Siqi
Qualitative research on criminal law of stealing network virtual property
Li yinqin
Civil rule of law
On the effectiveness of the parties’ agreement to attach property rights
Huang chenyu
Research on the Self-indulgent Adventure System in China’s Civil Code
Ding Dairui
On the new way of data monopoly regulation-legal examination of data portability right
Ma Jinfei
Research on the Legal Issues of Applying Safe Harbor Principle to Short Video Platform
Yang Yun
On the duty of care of network service providers in copyright infringement
Qiu Rong
Frontier problem
1. Analysis of the plight and outlet of minors’ right to fair and high-quality education
Author: Zhou Tong (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: At present, the protection of minors’ right to education in China has made great progress, but with the advancement of the digital age and the change of social environment, the protection of minors’ right to education is facing new challenges. With the improvement of people’s living standards, ensuring the fair and high-quality education rights of minors in the new era has gradually become an important measure to promote the full enjoyment of educational resources for the people. Although the newly revised and implemented relevant laws respond to the social concerns of the current social minors’ right to fair and high-quality education, there is still a division between theory and practice, which needs further improvement and regulation.
Keywords: minors’ right to education is fair and high-quality; minors’ right to education is protected by law and compulsory education is regulated.
2. On the judicial review of invalid administrative agreements.
Author: Wang Zhengchao (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: According to the Provisions of the Supreme People’s Court on Several Issues Concerning the Trial of Administrative Agreement Cases, both administrative legal norms and civil legal norms can be applied to the determination of invalid administrative agreements. However, the current legal norms are too general, and there are also some problems in the direct application of administrative acts and civil contracts to administrative agreements. In judicial practice, the application methods and order of administrative law and civil law are not clear enough, and the relationship between illegality and invalidity of administrative agreements is difficult to grasp. By sorting out the theoretical classification and changes of the judicial review mode of administrative agreements, this paper optimizes the review path of the invalidation of administrative agreements, and makes a normative explanation of the invalidation standards of administrative acts and civil contracts applied to administrative agreements from the perspective of jurisprudence, clarifying the relationship between "significant and obvious violation of laws and administrative regulations" and "violation of mandatory provisions" in order to improve the judicial review rules of administrative agreements.
Keywords: administrative agreement, invalid administrative agreement, invalid administrative litigation, standard law, dogmatic judicial review rules
3. On the expansion of the scope of compensation for mental damage caused by administrative infringement —— Based on the Interpretation of National Compensation for Mental Damage.
Author: Chen Wulue (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: On March 25th, 2021, the Supreme People’s Court officially published the Interpretation of the State Compensation for Mental Damage, which responded to the problems in the application of the State Compensation Law since it introduced the compensation system for mental damage. However, the problem of narrow scope of compensation for mental damage caused by administrative infringement has not been effectively solved. China’s civil mental damage compensation system has a rich theoretical and practical basis, and the Civil Code has improved the tort mental damage compensation, expanding the scope of the subject and the scope of the right to claim compensation. We can reflect on and learn from the content of civil compensation system for mental damage, and combine the characteristics of administrative activities to seek the expansion of the scope of mental damage due to administrative infringement from both the subject and the content, so as to fully protect the spiritual rights and interests of the administrative counterpart.
Keywords: state compensation, expansion of the scope of compensation for mental damage caused by administrative infringement, expansion of the scope of state compensation law
4. Predicament and outlet of full-time fact trial of people’s jurors
Author: Chen Qian (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: At the beginning of the establishment of the people’s jury system, people’s jurors and judges have the same position and power, and they have the power to comment on both factual and legal issues. The identification of legal issues by people’s jurors leads to the elite trend of jurors, which contradicts the value orientation of the people’s jury system. At the same time, there is still a conflict between the people’s jurors and the judges. Based on the above two reasons, it is imperative to reform the full-time fact trial of people’s jurors. However, there are theoretical dilemmas in the reform that the concepts of legal issues and factual issues are difficult to distinguish, as well as practical dilemmas that the list system of factual issues is difficult to implement, the priority presumption of factual issues is contrary to the original intention of the reform, and the disciplinary mechanism of people’s jurors is imperfect. Therefore, we should further improve the system construction of full-time fact trial of people’s jurors, distinguish objective facts from legal facts, specify the rules for making lists of facts, and establish a disciplinary mechanism for people’s jurors.
Keywords: people’s jurors full-time fact-finding list of facts, people’s jurors punish people’s jurors and reform judicial judgment
5. Study on the setting system of temporary administrative measures for major international activities.
Author: Yang Jiahao (Ph.D. candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: It is an important task for the government to ensure the smooth holding of major international activities. The administrative measures stipulated by the current laws and regulations can not meet the actual needs of the government’s various security work during the activities, so it is necessary to set up temporary administrative measures for possible security risks and emergencies. Because setting temporary measures will increase the burden on citizens, it is necessary for the Standing Committee of local people’s congresses to innovate China’s authorization legislation system and make a general authorization decision to provide a normative basis for the government to set temporary administrative measures. The temporary administrative measures set by the government according to the authorization should follow the four basic principles of efficiency, administration according to law, proportionality and human rights protection. In order to prevent the government from abusing temporary administrative measures to damage citizens’ rights, it is necessary to improve the supervision mechanism composed of the National People’s Congress, the administrative system itself and the court to review the legality and rationality of government actions.
Keywords: major international activities, administrative measures authorization decision-making system, temporary measures general authorization
6. On the "poverty alleviation" precise governance of national folk literature and art from the perspective of utilitarianism.
Author: Li Yuanhua (Ph.D. candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: In order to cope with the drastic change of production mode and social transformation, based on teleology and economic interest theory, the protection of national folk literature and art should turn to utilitarian governance. At present, the national folk literature and art has entered an uncontrollable "poverty" state, and it has fallen into an endogenous predicament because it can’t be integrated into the copyright law system, and it has fallen into an exogenous predicament because it can’t cope with the digital transformation. At the same time, it is facing a dispute over the legal basis. Therefore, it is urgent to carry out accurate governance of folk literature and art from the perspective of utilitarianism. First of all, we should complete the concept transformation from passive protection to active governance, from program protection to cultural governance, from meticulous protection to secular governance, from closed protection to market-oriented governance with different internal and external characteristics; Secondly, we should achieve precise governance in methodology, actively adapt to the protection system of copyright law, and actively adapt to the triple space composed of right subject, power subject and power subject; Finally, procuratorial public interest litigation, together with shared governance within the ethnic group and administrative power regulation outside the ethnic group, should jointly deal with the possible over-commercialization of folk literature and art governance under the market-oriented mechanism, and help folk literature and art to take the road of evolution.
Keywords: utilitarian poverty alleviation governance of ethnic and folk literature and art, limited marketization, precise governance of rights and obligations
7. On the legal liability for the loss caused by travel restriction in public health emergencies.
Author: Yu Jiacheng (Master of Constitutional Law and Administrative Law, School of Law, Zhejiang Gongshang University)
Abstract: In order to control the flow of people, China has implemented some travel restrictions. As a necessary part of the prevention and control of public health emergencies, these measures have caused unnecessary losses to citizens’ legitimate rights and interests. However, by analyzing the administrative nature of various travel restriction measures and the corresponding damage compensation methods, it can be known that the existing damage compensation measures are sparse in coverage and weak in compensation, and the actual effect is not good. In order to form a wide-ranging legal liability system for damage caused by travel restrictions, we should first clarify the state responsibility hidden behind the existing system and institutionalize and fix the existing damage compensation measures. At the same time, administrative compensation measures should be formulated as reinforcement measures, and flexible application space should be left for social equity compensation.
Keywords: prevention and control of public health emergencies, travel restrictions, damage compensation, administrative compensation and social equity compensation
Supervise the rule of law
1. The optimization of the connection path of the concept of "Fa Fa"
Author: Liu Hao (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: The supervisory organ is the "leading force" of anti-corruption governance in Socialism with Chinese characteristics, and the "co-location" of discipline inspection and supervision is the "innovative top-level design" of anti-corruption governance in Socialism with Chinese characteristics. In this process, the concept of supervision is the forerunner of the orderly development of supervision and corruption control activities. First of all, according to the rigid and flexible constraint nature of the concept, the supervision concept can be divided into two levels: the supervision concept at the level of "violation of discipline" and the supervision concept at the level of "violation of law" and "touching punishment"; Secondly, as far as the extension of the supervision concept is concerned, its essence is to highlight "politics", its value is to show "fairness" and its effectiveness is to show "strictness"; Furthermore, the reason for the poor connection between the supervision concept and the judicial concept is that the extension characteristics of the three concepts of the former may interfere with the authority, affect its independence and shake its equality. Finally, it is necessary to resort to the "rule by law" under the leadership of the Party and the "rule by law" with anti-corruption as the core to coordinate the supervision concept with the judicial concept and put in order.
Keywords: supervision concept, judicial concept, law and law convergence, judicial independence and equality principle, concept harmony
2. Visual analysis of research hotspots and frontiers of China’s supervision law —— Bibliometric research based on cnki database
Author: Cui Mengxue (Ph.D. candidate of Southeast University)
Abstract: From 1992 to 2021, China’s academic circles launched a wealth of research around the supervision law, and achieved certain research results. By using citespace, this paper makes a statistical analysis of 795 documents related to supervision law, which were included in the core journals of Peking University and cssci journals (including extended boards) in China Knowledge Network during this period, and respectively processes and studies them from the key words, the amount of articles published, the time of publication, the distribution of authors and research institutions, the distribution of articles published disciplines, and the distribution of articles published periodicals, so as to draw a visual knowledge map of the research hotspots and frontiers of supervision law in China. Based on the above data, this paper analyzes the research status of China’s academic circles in the field of supervision law in recent 30 years, evaluates and points out the hot spots and existing problems of the existing research, with a view to providing some suggestions and directions for the future research in the field of supervision law in China.
Keywords: supervision law, supervision system reform, visual analysis and bibliometrics research of supervision committee of supervision system
3. Feasibility analysis of setting prescription system in supervision law
Author: Lu Mengjiao (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: Prescription system is a basic rule of law system, which is widely used in civil law, criminal law and other legal systems. As a new compound right, supervision power integrates administrative supervision power, part of duty crime investigation power and supervision and prevention power. It is reasonable to consider the setting of prescription system and bring the supervision system into the track of rule of law. However, the convergence of the supervision system has not yet been put in place. In the current dual-track operating environment of government and administrative sanctions, administrative sanctions can still deal with the illegal acts of duty that have not been dealt with by government. Setting up the prescription system in the current supervision system will not only not play the role of the prescription system, but will also lead to the situation that the disposal right is transferred to the interior of the administrative organ, making the supervision right lose its supervision over the illegal acts of duty. In addition, the application of the prescription system of criminal acts in criminal law can also regulate duty crimes. Therefore, it is not appropriate to consider the prescription system of supervision power too hastily, and to prevent the prescription system from being ineffective.
Keywords:: prescription system supervision law, government disposition power, procuratorial power and rule of law
4. Probe into the principle of the right relief of the respondent in the supervision procedure.
Author: Niu Mengqian (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Summary: There is no doubt that the supervision law plays an important role in concentrating on cracking down on corruption cases, but if there is power, there must be restrictions. Under the strong supervision power, the legitimate rights and interests of the respondents are easily ignored. Although the supervision law stipulates the internal and external supervision of the supervisory organs, the supervision that has not been transformed into relief is not good supervision. Supervision itself is a means, not an end. Therefore, the legal rights and interests of the respondents are often in trouble. Apart from the general anti-corruption sentiment of the people, the reasons are that the remedies of the respondents are too single and narrow, and the means of external supervision by the supervisory organs have not been transformed into remedies, and the supervisory power itself has a high weight. Therefore, in order to promote the diversification and openness of the remedies for the rights of the respondents, we should follow the principles of giving priority to public remedies, exhausting internal remedies and ensuring the normal and smooth operation of the former two, so as to fully protect the legitimate rights and interests of the respondents during their supervision.
Keywords: supervision law, the rights of the respondent, relief and supervision organs, anti-corruption power constraints
5. Research on State Supervision Compensation System from the Perspective of Legislation
Author: Chen Shengnan (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: Under the background of the new era of upholding the rule of law in an all-round way and deepening the reform in an all-round way, the reform of the national supervision system goes hand in hand with the rule of law. Based on the deepening of the reform of the supervision system, the supervision compensation system, as an important part of the national supervision system and mechanism, is not only the basic embodiment of the principle of power restriction, but also the value orientation of highlighting the legal operation of supervision power and the consistency of powers and responsibilities. Considering the lack of legislation in the state supervisory compensation system and the particularity of supervisory power, on the basis of seeking the two-way connection between the supervisory compensation system and the state compensation system, this paper discusses its legislative path and initially constructs the basic framework of the state supervisory compensation system, with a view to filling the legislative gap of the supervisory compensation system and realizing the theoretical perfection and innovation of the supervisory compensation system.
Keywords:: supervision and compensation, legal connection, legislative path system, construction of the rule of law, power restriction
Criminal rule of law
1. The expansion and response of subjectivism in criminal law legislation
Author: Xu Jing (master student of Southeast University)
Abstract: The first criminal law promulgated in 1979 adopted the behaviorism position, and the core of conviction and sentencing was the infringement of legal interests by behavior. Since the Criminal Law Amendment (VIII), the subjectivism position has appeared, and the behaviorism position has been unable to meet the needs of current judicial practice. Subjectivism takes the subjective danger of the actor as the standard of conviction and sentencing, and externalizes it into the danger shown by the actor’s repeated illegal and criminal acts. Promoting subjectivism in legislation is conducive to ensuring the basic rights of criminals on the basis of eliminating their social harm. Analyze the characteristics of subjectivism and objectivism, and adjust the content of criminal law legislation to make appropriate improvements according to the current criminal situation. The expansion of subjectivism adapts to the needs of society, and at the same time, it is necessary to analyze the specific situation, find and standardize the risks contained in the expansion of subjectivism, and take appropriate measures to resist the possible risks.
Keywords: subjectivist criminal law legislation on special preventive security measures against personal danger
2. Research on the phenomenon that the sentencing suggestion of pleading guilty and admitting punishment is not adopted.
Author: Dai Minmin (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: The establishment of the lenient system of pleading guilty and admitting punishment has had a certain impact on sentencing suggestions. The system of pleading guilty and lenient punishment has not changed the fundamental attribute of sentencing suggestions, and it still has the nature of suggestions, but the provisions of Article 201 of the Criminal Procedure Law make it binding on court decisions. The completely different views of the court and the procuratorate on sentencing suggestions further lead to the confusion in the adoption of sentencing suggestions in practice, which hinders the development of the system of pleading guilty and recognizing punishment. Through the empirical investigation of sentencing suggestions, it is found that the court’s adoption of sentencing suggestions mainly has some problems, such as inconsistent acceptance standards, violation of procedural regulations, and insufficient communication between the legal and procuratorial parties. On the premise of recognizing that sentencing suggestions are procedural powers and binding to some extent, it is suggested to improve them from three aspects: establishing a correct concept of power of prosecution and trial, refining examination standards and strengthening communication between law enforcement and prosecution.
Keywords: guilty plea, lenient punishment system, sentencing suggestion, not adopting the standard judicial procedure of reviewing the relationship between prosecution and trial
3. On the implementation of "the same case and the same sentence" in criminal cases
Author: Liu Meng (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Summary: "Same case and same sentence" in criminal cases refers to "the same treatment of similar cases", which is not only the inherent requirement of the fairness and justice value of law and the principle of clarity of criminal law, but also the inevitable trend of responding to judicial chaos and people’s demands. The discussion of the specific connotation of "the same case and the same sentence" should be carried out in the specific context of departmental law. For "the same case", the criterion in the conviction stage is the constitution of the crime, and the criterion in the sentencing stage is the main sentencing circumstances; For "same sentence", cases with the same crime constitution and the same sentencing circumstances should be punished with the same penalty, and the limitation of knowledge level and the existence of discretionary sentencing circumstances allow differentiated judgments. In order to realize "the same case and the same sentence", on the one hand, it is necessary to strengthen the retrieval of similar cases in criminal justice, promote the compulsory retrieval mechanism of similar cases and the assistance of artificial intelligence to similar case retrieval; On the other hand, we should attach importance to the role of case guidance system in criminal justice, and at the same time, the local people’s courts should explicitly apply it when issuing guidance cases in the Supreme People’s Court.
Keywords: "the same case and the same sentence" in criminal cases, case retrieval, mandatory retrieval of big data case guidance system
4. Rebuilding the prosecution system of dealing with crimes only after telling them.
Author: Xu Yunjie (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: Looking at the current operation of the strict private prosecution system, there are some prominent problems, such as the lack of prosecution efficiency and improper intervention of public power. In essence, there is no conflict between the right of private prosecution and the right of state prosecution, and they are unified in protecting citizens’ rights. Therefore, removing the barriers of public prosecution and private prosecution and positioning the crime of handling only by telling as the nature of public prosecution will help solve the problem of functional failure and weak operation of strict private prosecution system. In order to overcome the infringement of private rights and the hard impact of state prosecution on social order, it is necessary to give full play to the horizontal supervision of power and the vertical restriction of rights at the same time, and to ensure the legitimacy of state prosecution and the autonomy of the exercise of rights through pre-trial meetings and granting citizens the right to self-determination. Reconstruct the dual prosecution mechanism with trial as the center and parallel public and private prosecution, respect the individual will of citizens on the basis of ensuring the effectiveness of the prosecution system, and connect with the criminal reconciliation system to form a complete and flexible relief system.
Keywords:: tell to deal with the crime of libel by public prosecution and private prosecution, and parallel public prosecution and private prosecution at the pre-trial meeting
5. Judicial Identification and Reflection on the Crime of Obstructing the Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases in the Form of Dual Crimes —— Taking 64 Judgment Documents as the Starting Point
Author: Liu Xiaoning (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: The basic crime of obstructing the prevention and treatment of infectious diseases has the dual criminal forms of specific dangerous crime and actual harmful crime. Based on the statistics and analysis of 64 judgment documents on the crime of obstructing the prevention and control of infectious diseases, there are four problems in the determination of dual crimes by judicial organs: first, the dilemma of distinguishing between "spread" and "serious danger"; Second, judging the logical misunderstanding; Thirdly, the emphasis on judging factors is only the result theory; Fourth, the tendency of abstract danger in identification. The above problems need to be solved from the theory of protecting the interests of the crime of preventing and controlling infectious diseases. Guided by the binary set theory of public health legal interests, the double serious danger rule can be used to distinguish "communication" from "serious danger" and "serious danger", and the binary result rule can be used for "communication".
Keywords: dual crime forms of the crime of obstructing the prevention and control of infectious diseases, specific dangerous crime, abstract dangerous crime and actual harmful crime, combining leniency with severity
6. The doctrinal analysis of criminal law on "raping abducted women"
Author: Wang Xuesong (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: The aggravated punishment for "raping a trafficked woman" is based on the fact that sexual assault under illegal control leads to the aggravation of illegality and responsibility; "Rape a trafficked woman" does not mean "rape a trafficked woman". The meaning of "rape" in the former is wider than that in the latter, but it does not include the sexual relationship between the perpetrator and the trafficked woman against the will of the woman, so "rape a trafficked woman" is not a joint crime in the strict sense. The criminal law amendment (11) supplements the aggravated circumstances of rape, which further makes the theory of "combined punishment for several crimes" against the act of "raping and abducting young girls" lose its rationality, and the only reasonable way is to explain "women" in substance; Whoever buys a trafficked woman and forcibly has sex with her and then sells it shall be punished as the crime of abducting and selling women and children; The participation of many people in "raping trafficked women" should be analyzed according to the theory of causal accomplice.
Keywords: rape and trafficking of women, rape of young girls, wrong motives, crime of trafficking in women and children causal accomplice
7. Analysis of criminal responsibility for stealing and digging black soil.
Author: Wang Xiaoli (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: Due to the lack of protection of black soil resources in China’s laws at present, there is a serious problem of different judgments on unauthorized soil mining in judicial practice. The application of the crime of illegal mining is suspected of violating the principle of a legally prescribed punishment for a crime. The application of the crime of illegal occupation of agricultural land cannot deal with the situation of legal occupation of land, and the sale of black soil does not belong to "illegal operation". Forced application will aggravate the "pocketing" of the crime of illegal operation. Black soil belongs to state-owned resources, and the act of stealing and digging black soil violates the state’s ownership of black soil resources, which conforms to the constitutive requirements of theft. Under the existing legislative framework, it should be evaluated as theft.
Keywords:: the crime of stealing and digging black soil mineral resources, illegal mining and theft constitute criminal responsibility
8. The applicable limits of the crime of infringing on the reputation and honor of heroic martyrs
Author: Unique (Master’s degree candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Summary: The Criminal Law Amendment (11) adds one of the 299th articles of the Criminal Law to the crime of infringing on the reputation and honor of heroic martyrs. It is not appropriate to abuse "insulting heroes and heroes" as the reason for the crime: among the elements of illegality, "heroic martyrs" should be interpreted restrictively and cannot become "heroic martyrs" in criminal law without the approval of competent authorities. The strong subjective condemnation of inappropriate speech is not the standard of "serious circumstances" Based on the particularity of network order, real social order and network order should not be confused when convicted; We should give full play to the important role of pre-law in governing the network environment, so it is not appropriate to establish the crime of infringing on the reputation and honor of heroic martyrs by publishing inappropriate comments about public figures on online social platforms.
Keywords:: the crime of infringing on the honor of heroic martyrs, the amendment to the criminal law, and the interpretation of the restriction of freedom of speech in honor infringement
9. Advocating the diversification of online fraud.
Author: Gong Wenbo (researcher, Research Center for Network Security and Rule of Law, Southeast University)
Abstract: With the development of network technology, online fraud in the web3.0 era has gradually shown the characteristics of large time and space span, non-contact, rapid spread and large number of people involved, which are different from traditional fraud. However, China still adopts the same way as traditional fraud, taking the amount as a single conviction standard, without combining the characteristics of online fraud, resulting in a high crime rate and a low conviction rate. At the same time, because online fraud only occurs in cyberspace, the transfer of crime sites does not change the nature of the behavior, and it is still necessary to invoke fraud to regulate online fraud. Reasonable demarcation of the judicial application boundary of online fraud should make the constitutive elements of online fraud diversified while keeping the amount of online fraud consistent with that of traditional fraud.
Keywords:: crime of fraud, network fraud, upgrading and cracking down on judicial application, constitutive requirements and conviction criteria
10. The legal interest structure and development of the crime of illegal business operation
Author: Zong Shaohao (Special Research Fellow, Anti-corruption and Rule of Law Research Center, Southeast University)
Abstract: The "pocketing" trend of the crime of illegal business operation originates from the judicial level, and the core lies in the improper definition of the content of legal interests. The traditional theory of order or system violates the principle of proportionality, deviates from the content of the principle of legal interest protection, and lacks substantive interests, which is no longer applicable to the current market economic system; The recent monistic theory of legal interest ignores the role of suprapersonal legal interest, and the deduced relationship and even the rank relationship advocated by it are unreasonable, which is inconsistent with the socialization trend of legal interest and makes the independence of the crime doubtful, which is not a reasonable conclusion of legal interest interpretation. The dual theory of legal interests, which is also a humanistic view of legal interests, is worth advocating. On this basis, the protection interest of the crime of illegal business operation should be the security of market economy, and it is necessary to refer to the legal interest established by the previous law to form a more accurate content of the lower security interest in the case. Subsequently, we should adopt the method of "formal incrimination standard+substantive incrimination standard" to scientifically judge whether it has reached the legal interest infringement worthy of punishment.
Keywords: "Pocket-oriented" dual legal interest theory of the crime of illegal business operation is beyond personal legal interest, and the essence of market economic security is guilty.
11. Judicial determination of the crime of infringing citizens’ personal information in the era of civil code
Author: Wang Siqi (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: The arrival of the era of civil code provides a strong pre-legal basis for the judicial determination of the crime of infringing citizens’ personal information. In order to ensure the unity of legal order, on the premise that the personality right of the civil code is compiled independently and the protection of personal information is absorbed in it, the identification of the criminal object of the crime of infringing on citizens’ personal information should be affected accordingly, and the concept definition should adopt the identification theory. At the same time, the "explicit consent" rule stipulated in the civil code should have an impact on the identification of the criminal object of this crime, and it should tend to identify the legal interests infringed by the crime of infringing on personal information as personal legal interests rather than super-personal legal interests. Finally, in terms of the objective identification of crime, the promulgation of the Civil Code will have an impact on the definition of the scope of "violation of relevant state regulations" and bring enlightenment to whether "illegal use of information" should be criminalized.
Keywords: the identification theory of the crime of infringing citizens’ personal information clearly agrees with the judicial identification of the theory of super-personal legal interests
12. Qualitative research on criminal law of stealing network virtual property.
Author: Li Yinyong (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: There is a dispute between the regulation theory of property crime and the regulation theory of data crime about the criminal law nature of stealing virtual property on the Internet. In the field of pre-law, the property of virtual property, which straddles the binary system of property and debt, will inevitably be linked with the characterization of behavior in criminal law. Interpreting virtual property as "property" in property crimes is actually an explanation of the principle of legality violation under the motivation of strengthening the protection of online virtual property interests, and it is realized by replacing the concept of "property" with the concept of "commodity" and "legal interest" with "interest" in criminal law. Restoring network virtual property belongs to the performance certificate of internet contract and the fact that the field of virtual property is different from the real world. Constructing an explanation path with legal interests as the guide, constitutive requirements as the core and the principle of suiting crime to punishment can lead to the rationality of regulating the theft of network virtual property by data crimes.
Keywords: stealing network virtual property, property data, legal interests, crime possessing property interests
Civil rule of law
1. On the effectiveness of the parties’ agreement to attach property rights.
Author: Huang Chenyu (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: Throughout the case of the execution of objections by outsiders such as Heshan Zhujiang Rural Bank and Guoshang Company, the core issue of the case lies in whether the ownership of the legal attachment can be decided in advance and the influence of the increase in the value of the mortgaged property due to the attachment on the scope of the mortgagee’s exercise of the mortgage. Now, the latter point has been solved by Article 41 of the Civil Code Interpretation of Guarantee System, which has changed its rules and is more reasonable and fair. That is, when the value of collateral changes due to attachment, the effective scope of mortgage is no longer linked to the ownership status of the attachment as in Article 62 of the original Interpretation of Guarantee Law, but only to the value of the original mortgage. However, the first dispute, that is, when the parties have an agreement, what is the ownership of the attachment after the movable property is attached to the real estate, and what kind of explanation should be made for the nature of the attachment behavior, has not been answered under the background of different judgments and incomplete reasoning of the two courts, and the real value is further studied.
Keywords: the ownership of the attached property right, the compulsory and arbitrary mortgage agreed by the parties
2. Research on the risk-taking system in the Civil Code.
Author: Ding Dairui (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: The risk-taking system stipulated in Article 1176 of the Civil Code is the first statutory exemption for "all-cause or nothing" in China’s tort law system, which has important practical significance. It is worthy of recognition that the establishment of the voluntary risk-taking system is helpful to improve judicial efficiency, encourage people to actively participate in cultural and sports activities and improve people’s physical fitness. However, there are some problems in the establishment of this system that need to be improved as soon as possible. The loopholes in the application of rules should be improved as soon as possible, and the responsibility between the victim and the offender or between the victim and the organizer should be handled with fairer and more reasonable rules, so as to better realize the original intention of the voluntary risk-taking system. Strictly limiting the scope of application, applying the principle of fault offset and stipulating the rules of victim consent can make this system more perfect.
Keywords:: willing to take risks, judicial efficiency, balance of interests, exemption, negligence and victim’s consent
3. On the legal review of the right of data portability
Author: Ma Jinfei (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: Under the situation of data monopoly, new enterprises often face many barriers to entry from law, technology and market, and the data monopolist can take advantage of its dominant market position to take a series of improper behaviors such as compulsory incompatibility, price discrimination and excessive collection of user privacy. At present, the European Union takes the lead in adopting the data portability right, and by giving the data subject the right to personal information, it explores a new way to indirectly regulate the data monopoly. However, there are some problems in the three aspects of "data portability right", such as data security risks, weak interoperability and the possibility of over-regulation, which need to be identified and prevented when we introduce it. In the current situation, it is not appropriate to directly stipulate the data portability right in the personal information protection law, but we should strengthen the theoretical research on the data portability right and the construction of supporting systems. When the conditions are ripe, we can explore adding the relevant provisions of "data portability right" in the form of legal amendment. When joining this clause, we should pay attention to joining the exemption system for small and medium-sized enterprises, expanding the scope of data subjects and strengthening the connection with other laws.
Keywords: personal information protection, data portability, general data protection regulations, data monopoly, data access convergence
4. Research on the legal issues of short video platform applying the safe haven principle.
Author: Yang Yun (Master candidate, Southeast University Law School)
Abstract: With the development of Internet technology, users gradually break the time and space constraints for entertainment consumption. In this context, the short video communication mode came into being. The low threshold of short video production not only greatly inspired the creative enthusiasm of the public, but also brought huge economic benefits to the platform. However, with the sinking of the market, the quality of short video content becomes more and more difficult to guarantee, and the phenomenon of copyright infringement such as video handling between users becomes more and more serious. In this regard, the obligee thinks that the platform’s duty of care should be increased, so that it can’t enjoy the traffic bonus brought by short videos while using the "notification-removal" procedure to easily enter the "safe haven". However, short video platforms often refuse to bear the responsibility of being triggered by users uploading infringing short videos themselves on the grounds that they have no obligation to review the legality of copyright. In view of the conflict of interests between the two parties, how to apply the safe haven principle to better reconcile the demands of both parties has become an urgent problem to be solved at present.
Keywords: short video safe haven principle duty of care "notice-delete" platform Internet
5. On the duty of care of Internet service providers in copyright infringement.
Author: Qiu Rong (Master candidate, School of International Law, East China University of Political Science and Law)
Abstract: Duty of care is an important factor to judge whether network service providers need to bear indirect tort liability, and the establishment of its connotation and applicable standards is very important for copyright protection in the network environment. When setting the duty of care of network service providers, we should base on the principle of balance of interests, clarify the functional orientation of the duty of care of network service providers in China’s copyright law, and at the same time, we should comprehensively consider the types of network service providers, tort, infringing objects and non-neutral behaviors of network service providers and other factors that affect the applicable standards of duty of care. On this basis, we should promote the construction of the standard of duty of care of network service providers, and clearly set the duty of care of network service providers at different stages of infringement, so as to further protect the rights and interests of copyright owners and the public, and create a harmonious society.
Keywords: Internet service providers’ duty of care for infringement, balance of interests of applicable standards of copyright

Shangguan author: Shanghai Law Society








